Skip to content
All case studies

How to choose between Solar and a Diesel Generator

Key design choices and calculations that help you decide between solar backup and a diesel generator — then how REST Automation helps you make the right call.

When the grid fails in Accra, Tema, or Kumasi, the question is rarely whether you need backup — it is which backup. Diesel generators are familiar, fast to rent, and loud. Solar-plus-battery systems are quieter, cleaner, and more expensive up front. The right answer depends on your load, how long you need autonomy, and how you value fuel, noise, and maintenance over three to seven years.

This guide walks through the design choices and the calculations REST Automation uses in early scoping. It is not a substitute for a site survey — it is the decision framework we use before we size hardware.

The five design choices that matter

  • Load profile — which circuits must stay on, and at what continuous and surge watts.
  • Autonomy — how many hours (or days) of outage you need to cover without fuel top-ups.
  • Runtime pattern — short evening outages versus multi-day industrial downtime.
  • Noise, emissions, and space — generator setbacks, exhaust, and neighbour constraints.
  • Cash vs lifecycle cost — capital today versus fuel and service over the system life.

Step 1 — Size the daily load

Start with a critical-load list. For each appliance, multiply watts × hours per day × quantity, then sum to get daily energy in kilowatt-hours (kWh).

LoadWattsHours / dayQtykWh / day
LED lighting120610.72
Fridge / freezer1801011.80
Fans75831.80
Wi-Fi + TV150510.75
Phone / laptop charging100410.40
Total5.47
Example critical-load day for a three-bedroom home

Add a 20–30% contingency for unknown loads and inverter losses. In this example, plan around ~7 kWh/day of usable battery energy for a full night of backup.

5.5 kWhModeled loadCritical circuits only
~7 kWhWith contingencyUsable battery target
3–5 kVAPeak surge bandInverter class

Step 2 — Diesel fuel and runtime cost

A small residential generator (5–8 kVA) might burn roughly 1.0–1.8 litres per hour at typical household load. At Ghana diesel prices, that becomes a recurring cash cost every outage night — plus oil changes, filters, and eventual rebuilds.

AssumptionValue
Fuel burn at load1.4 L / hour
Diesel price (illustrative)GHS 15 / L
Cost per hourGHS 21
Outage hours / month40 hours
Monthly fuel onlyGHS 840
Annual fuel onlyGHS 10,080
Illustrative diesel operating cost (5–8 kVA class)

Over five years, fuel alone can exceed GHS 50,000 before maintenance — often more than the premium of a well-sized solar-plus-battery package for the same critical loads. Your numbers will differ; the method does not.

Step 3 — Solar and battery sizing

For solar backup, battery capacity must cover the autonomy window. Panels must recharge that battery on a typical Accra sun day (peak sun hours ≈ 4.5–5.5 depending on roof and season).

  1. Battery usable kWh ≈ daily critical load × days of autonomy ÷ depth-of-discharge factor.
  2. Inverter kVA ≥ continuous critical watts ÷ 0.8, with headroom for motor surge.
  3. PV kWp ≈ (daily kWh ÷ peak sun hours) × system loss factor (often 1.2–1.4).
Comparison schematic of solar-plus-battery backup versus a diesel generator for a home critical-load circuit
Same critical loads, two energy paths — solar stores daytime generation; diesel converts fuel on demand.

Step 4 — Lifecycle comparison

Compare capital, fuel, service, and soft costs (noise complaints, fuel logistics, downtime when the set fails to start). The table below is a planning illustration for a home critical-load scenario — not a quote.

Cost lineDiesel generatorSolar + battery
Upfront hardware + installLowerHigher
Fuel over 5 yearsHigh and volatileNear zero for backup use
Routine serviceFrequent (oil, filters)Lower (inspections, firmware)
Noise / emissionsHighSilent at night
Grid-tied daytime valueNoneOffsets daytime bills
Typical 5-year TCO trendFuel-dominatedCapex-dominated, then flat
5-year total cost of ownership (illustrative, critical-load home)

Decision summary

  • Map critical watts and daily kWh first — never size from generator kVA alone.
  • Price diesel on hours × litres × fuel, not on purchase price.
  • Size solar on autonomy and recharge, not on panel count marketing.
  • Revisit the choice when loads grow (AC, pumps, workshops) — hybrids are common.

Let REST Automation help you decide

Bring your load list or a rough floor plan. We model solar, diesel, and hybrid options with Ghana-aware sun hours and pricing assumptions — then you choose with numbers, not guesswork.

Book a consultationSize your solar system

Next step

Ready to scope your own project?

Whether you are weighing solar against diesel, or scoping a smart-home package, we turn the numbers into a clear plan.